The Evolving Pitch Process - Why Brands Should Approach Agency Selection Differently
How easy is it to stay in an unhealthy relationship that isn’t the perfect fit? Months or maybe years pass after committing and then there is the sudden realization that “they” are not “the one.”
Or maybe it has been a long time coming but the pain of starting over with someone new is too hard, so you find yourself settling instead.
Finding “the one” is stressful, time consuming, and, to be honest, extremely hard. A romantic relationship is not exactly congruent to an agency-client relationship, but there is something to be said about agency selection and the evolving pitch process.
Is the pitch process dying? No, but it is changing. This Ad Age article highlights brands like Domino’s and their decision to take the agency pitch in a different direction.
Current pitches require agencies to spend money, loads of time, and resources on a flashy presentation that does not:
Assess the agency’s compatibility with the brand
Showcase if the agency’s capabilities fit the current need
How can the Pitch Process Change to Benefit all Parties - Agencies and Clients alike?
It’s simple. Date.
No need for romantic gestures with boomboxes, dance numbers, or flowers, but a sit-down conversation where the agency can interview the brand and the brand can interview the agency.
Similar to most pitch presentations, brands need to ask themselves the following questions during the conversation:
Do the agency’s rates fit in the budget?
Do the agency’s objectives align with the strategy?
Will the agency represent or capture the brand’s voice correctly in content materials?
Can the agency handle the ask?
In order to gauge the agency’s capabilities, ask that the agency prepare case studies of their past work that relates to the brand’s current need.
But different from the typical pitch, chemistry should be the brand’s primary focus.
Is there chemistry?
In order for this assessment to take place, ask that the agency team that will handle the project take part in the pitch. As opposed to the bait and switch situation where the client meets the A team and, instead, works with the C team, ask to meet the entire team from the beginning.
This may seem silly, but chemistry is the most important aspect in a relationship. Both parties need to be comfortable with being honest and transparent. An agency is an extension of a brand’s internal team. A solid communication and relationship could positively influence the direction of ideas and projects.
Conversation, not presentation.
You don’t put on a spectacular play for your first date.
Having a direct conversation will save time and prevent nasty breakups down the road. A straightforward meeting spins the “presentation” in a different light to gain new insights and will also make it easier to onboard the agency for future projects since the groundwork is already laid.
Truly “date” your agencies before you launch into a long term commitment. Get the best feel and don’t settle for an agency (even if the process to onboard a new agency may be unpalatable).
As true matchmakers between brand marketers and marketing agencies, Setup knows where the agency-client relationship struggles. Even if you implement personal conversations with every agency prospect, this process still takes a decent amount of time. We help by performing a thorough vetting process of outstanding agencies to simplify your onboarding process and bring you one step closer to finding the perfect match.
Read Related - Why Big Brands Are Turning To Small Agencies
NAVIGATE THE AGENCY SELECTION PROCESS EFFECTIVELY.
The Complete Guide to Finding a Marketing Agency
This guide teaches client-side marketers to how to plan, select, and onboard marketing agencies to get the most value from the partnership in the long run.
Click here to download the free, interactive PDF.
Media is about delivering results that are meaningful. Your strategy should be about more than impressions. But with siloed data and rising expectations, it's hard to prioritize meaning under pressure to perform.
That’s why we’ve brought together three powerful blogs filled with insights from industry experts at the top of their media game to help you rethink your media planning, simplify execution, and activate smarter strategies that drive growth.
“Data-driven” marketing is about proactively leveraging insights to make strategic decisions. But what defines a truly data-driven media approach?
Creating a marketing budget isn’t just a financial exercise; it’s a strategic act. It’s your roadmap for growth, your guardrail against wasted effort, and, when done well, your strongest case for internal alignment and external results.
But while most marketers know how much they wish they could spend, far fewer know how much they should. So, where do you begin?
Marketers today juggle numerous platforms, overwhelming data, and competing internal demands, creating a complex media landscape that clouds performance clarity. What drives this complexity, and how can brands effectively navigate it?
Today’s marketers face immense pressure to justify media spend and measure tangible impact. But fragmented data, inadequate tracking, and unclear KPIs often cloud visibility. How can brands build smarter strategies that truly connect media spend to real business outcomes?
At Setup, we don’t just listen, we track patterns, analyze them, and come up with solutions to assist marketers with their challenges. Every year, our Marketing Relationship Survey gathers insights from brand and agency marketers to identify the core challenges, shifts, and opportunities in the client–agency relationship. These aren’t hypotheticals; they’re real-time questions marketing leaders are actively asking. And your answers help drive the industry's evolution.
Every few years, we revisit the Health and Wellness space to track major shifts. Since the pandemic, the industry has made significant strides to meet evolving consumer demands and expectations.
We spoke with Mark Yosick, Senior Marketing Director, Surgical at MIMEDX, about his experience in the space, the challenges he’s faced, and the trends he sees shaping the future.
In the last five years, the health and wellness industry has experienced a significant transformation, from personalized nutrition, to the rise of telehealth, to a growing emphasis on marketing transparency. The consumer is becoming more integral in everyday decisions across all industries.
What has changed and what is continuing to take priority in today’s health and wellness sector?
Setup CEO + Founder, Joe Koufman, sat down with Navin Sharma, Chief Marketing Officer at Church’s Texas Chicken, to talk about the importance of hard work, resilience, and why simply getting started is often the most imperative step to success.
When it comes to purchasing, today’s consumers want more than just a product–they want something to believe in. The rise of purpose-driven brands, founder visibility, AI-powered personalization (with boundaries), and culturally rooted storytelling are reshaping how beverage companies connect with their audiences.
BLK & Bold, a coffee brand built on community, culture, and impact, is a leader in this movement. In this exclusive interview with Co-Founder Rod Johnson, Johnson shares how they’re redefining what it means to market in the beverage space.
At Setup, we work with some of the finest marketing agencies across the nation–each with a unique set of capabilities. Our most recent virtual event gave our partners a platform to share an exclusive behind-the-scenes look into their process, strategy, and campaign results for an array of industries in under two hours. Ten case studies in 90 minutes and a little friendly competition.
In a conversation with Nate Bigger, Founder + CEO of MONPURE and the leader behind the brand’s marketing strategy, we heard firsthand how the company is navigating the beauty landscape with authenticity, science-led storytelling, and a deep understanding of the emotional side of self-care.
We’ve analyzed ten years of data to uncover the five biggest challenges agencies face when it comes to pitching, and how they can put their best foot forward to present themselves thoroughly and honestly, and win the client.
Setup CEO + Founder, Joe Koufman, spoke with Joshua Sims Sr., the Chief Marketing Officer at Noble Food and Pursuits about how he prioritizes relationships and embodies the humanization of marketing.
The financial services industry has never been known for moving fast—but in 2025, the pressure is on. With artificial intelligence (AI) redefining customer engagement, fintech innovations raising consumer expectations, and tighter regulations around data privacy, marketing leaders in finance are rethinking how they show up, connect, and grow.
With agentic AI systems driving automation, fintech innovations setting new standards, and post-pandemic digital acceleration cementing permanent shifts in behavior, the financial marketing landscape is evolving at a rapid speed. So, how can financial brands stay ahead?
Is AI stripping consumers of excitement? Is there unconscious bias in AI? How can marketers stand out while using the same tech stack?
In conversations with marketing leaders in the high-tech and innovation sector, adopting AI is not the challenge. The future belongs to teams who adapt to AI while investing in human elements like curiosity, connection, and inspiration.
Advancements in AI over the last few years have shifted customer expectations. With all of this power and access, however, comes more responsibility on marketers to lead with intention and care. Explore the biggest shifts in High-tech + Innovation and how marketing leaders can act accordingly.
When it comes to picking an agency, chemistry between brands and agencies is often overlooked in the selection process, but it’s one of the biggest indicators of long-term success. Yes, you need a business partner with the right capabilities and experience, but when it comes down to the final candidates, chemistry is what truly sets long-term partners apart.
At Setup, we’ve had the privilege of speaking with some of the most influential women in marketing over the years—leaders who are driving change and making an impact in their organizations and beyond. Here’s what we’ve learned from their stories.
Great marketers never stop learning—so how are you investing in your team’s growth? From leadership coaching to AI-driven innovation, this blog explores the most effective professional development strategies to keep your marketing team sharp, engaged, and ahead of the curve.
Gratitude is the primary word I think of when reflecting on the 11th anniversary this month for Setup. This anniversary is not just a celebration of Setup—it’s a celebration of you. Whether you’re a client who has placed trust in our process, an agency that has joined our network, a partner who has supported our journey, or a friend who has cheered us on, your support has been invaluable.
The path to growth for marketing Agencies in 2025 is no longer about simply acquiring new Clients; it’s about scaling effectively. With evolving Client demands, technological advancements, and increasing competition, Agencies must focus on strategies that enable sustainable and efficient expansion.
Based on insights from Setup’s research, expert advice, and industry trends over the last 10 years, here are five key strategies to help Agencies scale effectively in 2025.
The Setup Marketer Speed Dating event is one of our personal favorite longstanding #MarketersBreakfast events because of the ease and quality of the connections fostered. Established Atlanta Brands and our Agency partners come together to mix, mingle, and enjoy one another’s company in a fast-paced, pitch-free environment where forming a genuine connection is at the core of the interaction.
Super Bowl LIX wasn’t just about football—it was a masterclass in marketing. Each year, brands gamble big (to the tune of $8 million per 30-second ad) for a chance to capture the nation’s attention. With such high stakes, the challenge isn’t just making a good ad—it’s making an ad that resonates long after the final whistle blows.
This year, amid a landscape of economic uncertainty and shifting consumer sentiment, many brands leaned away from risk-taking and played it safe. "Nowstalgia"—pairing rising stars with established icons—dominated, while humor, celebrity cameos, and absurdist comedy took center stage. And while some brands nailed it, others flopped despite their star-studded casts.
Setup CEO + Founder, Joe Koufman, spoke with Sergio Pérez, the Chief Marketing Officer at Emmy Squared, a pizza restaurant founded in 2014 with 10 locations across the East coast. Sergio Pérez champions curiosity, authenticity, and the underdog spirit.
As competition intensifies and Clients get more selective about what they want, Agencies must navigate hurdles that directly affect their ability to meet Client expectations and learn to adjust. Let’s dive into the core obstacles Agencies are tackling this year, why they’re critical to address, and practical strategies to stay ahead in an ever-changing industry.
Choosing the right marketing Agency in 2025 is about more than finding a vendor—it’s about building a partnership that can adapt to your needs, communicate effectively, and drive long-term results. Start with clear goals, leverage trusted referrals, and prioritize compatibility and communication. Remember, the right Agency won’t just execute campaigns—they’ll act as an extension of your team, helping your Brand navigate challenges and seize opportunities.
While our previous blogs recapping the Marketing Relationship Survey highlight key communication tactics and needs to sustain and improve the Agency-Client relationships, today we’re simply asking: What kind of work is getting noticed and needed by Clients, and what should Agencies prioritize?
In the midst of change and new tech, Marti Walsh, VP of Customer Experience and Marketing at Kimberly-Clark Professional, brings us back to what really matters: showing up with purpose. In this conversation with Setup, she shares how her team builds trust through consistent omnichannel messaging, thoughtful use of AI, and a commitment to authenticity that connects with real people.