How Client-Side Marketers Find Marketing Agencies
According to the 2023 Setup Marketing Relationship Survey, Word-of-mouth and Referrals consistently remain the most frequent methods Clients use to find new Agency Partners.
This has been the case for the last five years of the Marketing Relationship Survey.
When forming partnerships of any kind, trust is a huge component. Clients are asking friends and colleagues for recommendations, or even hiring members from old Agency partnerships (that’s why it’s best to never burn a bridge in the networking world).
The data shows that ¾ of marketers are finding agencies via Word of Mouth with a nearly 20% increase from the previous year. Clients want to hear from a trusted source rather than take a chance on putting effort into finding a marketing partner that ends up not being the right fit.
What does this mean for Client-side marketers?
Only relying on Word of Mouth may seem like the easiest solution since the Agency search process is so daunting, but Word of Mouth referrals have their limitations. If we only relied on our immediate friends and family recommendations for food, clothes, anything, then there is a huge gap of missing potential. Why do you think people travel abroad? To learn and discover more than what is offered in their immediate surroundings.
Think about the lost potential.
In the last year, the Marketing Relationship Survey showed that Procurement and Internet Search moved up as means to find a marketing Agency, rising above events. Investing more in the Agency search and putting in work in the front end is a great way to expand your horizons and put less work into the backend since you’ll have a solid partnership with a qualified Agency. However, Events is ranking low as a method to find an Agency. Does this mean Clients are relying more on digital searches?
Regardless, all of this effort takes time. 84% of Clients involved in the Agency selection process actually find it time-consuming because they have to uncover and assess the capabilities, chemistry, and experience of several agencies before finding the perfect match. Setup offers services, some of which are free to Clients, to help Clients find the best Agency that suits their needs all the while saving time, money, and resources.
These marketing services include:
Marketing Ecosystem Consulting - Gauge your team’s current operations and determines the resources you need to succeed.
Custom Agency Search - Explore your marketing goals and Agency needs, and then conduct a nation-wide, custom Agency partner search.
In-Network Agency Search - Talk through your marketing goals and Agency needs, and then refer you to a qualified Agency within the Setup Agency network at no cost to you.
What does this mean for marketing Agencies?
Cold outreach emails and cold calling will not get your foot in the door. Clients are responding to warm introductions with previously established relationships. Meaning chemistry is more important than ever.
Four steps to developing more chemistry with a Client-side Marketer include:
Communication
Understanding the person
Understanding the business
Viewing each other as a partner
These may seem obvious, but miscommunication is the root to all relationship problems. Read Building Chemistry in the Agency-Client Relationship for detailed steps on how to approach getting to know your marketing contact and Client better.
If you are a marketing Agency and relationships are failing and deals are still not coming through, dig deeper into who you are as an Agency. Evaluate your marketing stack, departments, internal communications, Business Development efforts, and more. Sometimes taking a look into the mirror and understanding yourself better will help you sell yourself better. If you need help, Setup has multiple services to help agencies level up.
These marketing services include:
Agency Assessment - Provides agencies with an in-depth SWOT analysis and action items from data collected from internal and external stakeholder interviews.
Agency Mastermind - A curated, peer-to-peer mentoring group of marketing Agency (10-50 FTEs) owners who meet monthly to discuss, brainstorm, support, and advise each other to solve problems and develop personally or professionally.
Team Building - Harnesses team bonding and development organically through improv exercises.
Business Development Training - Arranges a customized workshop for your team to refine your BD strategy.
Marketing Diagnostic - Evaluates Client-facing messaging and recommends methods to differentiate.
Setup also partners with agencies to provide them with the right opportunities - sometimes by providing that warm introduction that gets an agency’s foot in the door through our Sustainable Pipeline offering. Let us be the Word of Mouth referrals for you!
By annually surveying the marketing community with the Marketing Relationship Survey, our hope is that we can bring to light behaviors and gaps between the Agency-Client Relationship. By understanding one another better, and by making the moves to better serve and work with one another, we can all save a little bit more time, energy, and resources, and finally check out that coffee shop your good friend recommended. WINK WINK
At Setup, we sit in the middle of these relationships every day. We see what happens when a client sets an agency partnership up to win and what happens when they accidentally set it up to fail. So if you want better work, better chemistry, and better results, here are the most common “client behaviors” that signal trouble, plus what to do instead.
Designing for real life means embedding authenticity across the entire customer journey — from product to service to story — in ways that remove friction and deliver measurable and meaningful results.
Marti Walsh, the VP of Customer Experience and Marketing at Kimberly-Clark Professional, shares what it means to be an authentic leader and how to optimize operations honorably.
In the last six years, we’ve surveyed thousands of brands and agencies about their relationships. Each year, the data tells the story that brands want a partner they can rely on, but finding that partner often is difficult, expensive, and time consuming.
Read what brands are looking for in the perfect agency partner.
Setup’s 2025 Marketing Relationship Survey gives marketers a rare, honest look into what brands and agencies say is working and what quietly destroys partnerships.
The truth is that relationships fail because of patterns, mistakes that pile up over time, even after multiple warnings. So here are the most common red flags and green flags in the agency-client relationship based on what real marketers are telling us.
Setup CEO + Founder, Joe Koufman, sat down with Gabie Boko, the Chief Marketing Officer for NetApp, to talk about staying consumer focused, being bold, and loving the LEGO brand.
Super Bowl LX showcased brands pushing weight loss drugs, AI, and utilizing celebrities to an absurd amount (what’s new?), as well as another “Minions" movie in theaters (surprised but not shocked). Every marketer weighs in on who won their hearts…and this year, for us, it came down to brands that leaned into storytelling that included nostalgia and emotion, specifically with a human lens.
And if you’ve ever been blindsided by a brand-agency breakup (from either side), you’re not alone. The 2025 Marketing Relationship Survey shows something that’s both surprising and painfully familiar:
Brands aren’t racing to leave… but they’re also not thrilled.
Setup CEO + Founder, Joe Koufman, sat down with Don McGuire, the EVP and Chief Marketing Officer for Qualcomm, to talk about seizing the moment of opportunity, empathetic leadership, Louis Vuitton, and more.
The annual Setup Marketing Relationship Survey reveals a growing disconnect between what clients say ends agency relationships (delivery + value) and what agencies think ends them (budget cuts + leadership changes). If you want stronger partnerships and better outcomes in 2026, this report highlights exactly where relationships break and how to fix them.
Setup CEO + Founder, Joe Koufman, sat down with Brett Hannath, the Corporate VP, Global Marketing of Intel, to talk problem solving, transparent leadership, the bricks-and-mortar experience, and more.
Over the past year, we’ve watched the following patterns emerge across seemingly unrelated sectors: rising consumer expectations, demand for authenticity, growing complexity, and the tension between automation and human connection.
We interviewed multiple marketers from an array of industries in our blogs below, and we discovered consistent trends across the board. Check out all of our industry blogs throughout 2025 from leaders at Blackbaud, Hiscox USA, Mimedx, MONPURE, Kimberly-Clark Professional, and more.
A call for marketers and agencies to participate in the 2025 Marketing Relationship Survey, before it’s too late.
On November 19, 2025, Atlanta’s vibrant marketing community united under one roof for the first-ever Atlanta Integrated Marketing Summit (AIMS) — a remarkable experience that turned inspiration into action, focused on meaningful connections, and highlighted incredible leaders from UPS, Kellanova, Edible Brands, and Papa Johns who are actively pushing the industry forward.
Explore the denim duel between AE’s Sydney Sweeney campaign and Gap’s Milkshake-fueled comeback—and what marketers can learn.
Most agency searches begin with urgency: a priority shift, a launch date appears, and suddenly, you’re writing an RFP at midnight. In that scramble, you invite too many firms, ask the wrong questions, and end up choosing based on pitch theater instead of day-to-day fit. The fix isn’t a better RFP template. It’s time - specifically, the time you spend getting to know agencies before you need one.
Marketers are grappling with how to make their strategy feel more impactful and human in 2025, but in the nonprofit world, that challenge comes with the added pressure of limited budgets and expansive missions. For Lynn Godfrey, Chief Experience Officer at Blood Cancer United, the solution lies in staying intentional, deeply segmenting audiences, and adapting quickly in a constantly evolving landscape.
Private wealth marketing is built on personal relationships, which can make the advancements in technology more and more challenging. In an industry where discretion and relationships reign supreme, marketers must learn how to integrate data, automation, and innovation without losing trust.
To explore this balance, we spoke with Cathy McLagan, Managing Director of Growth Enablement at CIBC Private Wealth US.
“Data-driven” marketing is about proactively leveraging insights to make strategic decisions. But what defines a truly data-driven media approach?
If your media strategy feels tangled and unclear, you’re not alone. Here’s how smart brands are simplifying the chaos and getting real results.
Whether you’re managing campaigns for a national brand, a franchise QSR, or a B2B tech company, the challenge is the same: how do you build smarter media strategies that actually tie back to real business outcomes? We spoke with top experts from Sagepath, Goodway Group, and Look Listen to dig into what’s working, what’s changing, and where media performance and analytics are headed next.
Retail marketing is entering a new era where value, trust, and operational excellence matter more than volume, visibility, and trend-chasing. As shopper expectations evolve, smart retail marketers are embracing personalization, AI, and brand positioning that aligns with customer values. We spoke with Kaylin Staub, the Chief Marketing Officer at SupplyHouse, and a leader we believe to be leading the pack in these efforts. Check out her interview.
In the midst of change and new tech, Marti Walsh, VP of Customer Experience and Marketing at Kimberly-Clark Professional, brings us back to what really matters: showing up with purpose. In this conversation with Setup, she shares how her team builds trust through consistent omnichannel messaging, thoughtful use of AI, and a commitment to authenticity that connects with real people.
Media is about delivering results that are meaningful. Your strategy should be about more than impressions. But with siloed data and rising expectations, it's hard to prioritize meaning under pressure to perform.
That’s why we’ve brought together three powerful blogs filled with insights from industry experts at the top of their media game to help you rethink your media planning, simplify execution, and activate smarter strategies that drive growth.
“Data-driven” marketing is about proactively leveraging insights to make strategic decisions. But what defines a truly data-driven media approach?
Creating a marketing budget isn’t just a financial exercise; it’s a strategic act. It’s your roadmap for growth, your guardrail against wasted effort, and, when done well, your strongest case for internal alignment and external results.
But while most marketers know how much they wish they could spend, far fewer know how much they should. So, where do you begin?
Marketers today juggle numerous platforms, overwhelming data, and competing internal demands, creating a complex media landscape that clouds performance clarity. What drives this complexity, and how can brands effectively navigate it?
Today’s marketers face immense pressure to justify media spend and measure tangible impact. But fragmented data, inadequate tracking, and unclear KPIs often cloud visibility. How can brands build smarter strategies that truly connect media spend to real business outcomes?
At Setup, we don’t just listen, we track patterns, analyze them, and come up with solutions to assist marketers with their challenges. Every year, our Marketing Relationship Survey gathers insights from brand and agency marketers to identify the core challenges, shifts, and opportunities in the client–agency relationship. These aren’t hypotheticals; they’re real-time questions marketing leaders are actively asking. And your answers help drive the industry's evolution.
Jose Villa, the President & Chief Strategy Officer at Sensis and Chair of the Hispanic Marketing Council, shares his thoughts on Multicultural marketing - where marketers are spending and where consumers are shopping when fear and uncertainty take precedence.