Agency Assessment

Know where your marketing agency fits and where it can win.

Agency Assessment is required onboarding for agencies that have signed and joined the Setup Agency Collective. We review your existing work and evidence to develop an ideal-client profile and practical guidance for matching your agency with relevant brand opportunities. It is required onboarding, not an application or acceptance test.

Assessment begins after your Setup Agency Collective agreement is signed.

Why Agency Assessment Exists

Build the foundation for a better growth relationship.

A capabilities deck alone does not give Setup enough information to understand where an agency is most likely to succeed.

Agency Assessment creates an evidence-based picture of your strongest clients, best-fit opportunities, positioning, proof, readiness and potential limitations. That clarity helps your agency focus its growth efforts and helps Setup evaluate future brand opportunities more responsibly.

What the Assessment Clarifies

A clearer view of where your agency is strongest.

Ideal client fit

Define the clients, buyers, categories, budgets and business situations where your agency is most likely to succeed, as well as the work it should avoid.

Positioning

Clarify how the agency should communicate its specialization, value, differentiation and relevance.

Proof

Evaluate whether case studies, outcomes, references and supporting evidence substantiate the agency’s strongest claims.

Opportunity readiness

Identify the types of client needs, scopes and working conditions that fit your agency’s proven strengths. For a specific brand opportunity, Setup separately checks current capacity, conflicts, timing and other practical requirements.

How It Works

From Collective agreement to better matching guidance.

During contracting, Setup and your agency agree on the Assessment scope, including whether client, staff or leadership surveys are included. After the Collective agreement is signed, your agency completes one Intake and shares existing materials. Setup reviews the evidence, discusses the proposed findings with you and finalizes its internal matching guidance.

Agree on the scope.

After a fit conversation and invitation to the Collective, we agree on the No Surveys or With Surveys path, fee and timing in the signed agreement. The Assessment begins after you join.

Share existing materials.

Complete one consolidated Intake and provide available capabilities, case studies, results, positioning and commercial guidance. You do not need to create new case studies for this process.

Review the evidence.

Setup studies your strongest work, client patterns, capabilities and boundaries. If surveys were included in your signed scope, Setup also reviews that feedback.

Develop the guidance.

Setup proposes an ideal-client profile, best-fit opportunity situations, credible proof, poor-fit conditions and practical priorities.

Discuss and align.

We walk through the findings together in an Assessment Review Presentation. Setup then finalizes its internal Agency Profile and Opportunity Match Card for ongoing matching.

What the Agency Receives

A clearer picture of where your agency fits.

Your agency participates in an Assessment Review Presentation and discussion of its proposed ideal-client profile, strengths, evidence gaps, best-fit situations and priorities. When surveys are included in the signed scope, we discuss the reviewed, de-identified feedback. Your input helps Setup finalize the guidance it uses to recognize relevant opportunities.

Better information supports better opportunity fit.

Setup uses the agreed profile and matching guidance to consider relevant brand needs. We still evaluate the details of each live opportunity, including current capacity, conflicts, timing and proof, before sharing it with your agency.

The Assessment itself does not guarantee opportunities; the signed Collective agreement governs any opportunity commitment.

Agency Perspective

Outside perspective your agency can act on.

When targeted external feedback is included, it can help an agency see its business through the perspective of the clients and staff who know its work best.

Perspective from an Agency Assessment that included external client and staff feedback

“The analysis into our shop and its business was very insightful. We appreciated hearing the feedback, both the good and the constructive, from our staff and clients. It gave us plenty to work on as we look to become an even more effective and impactful agency.”
Paul Brusatori, Intermark

Agency Assessment FAQ

Common questions about Agency Assessment.

Answers to common questions about onboarding after signing, the consolidated Intake, survey scope agreed during contracting, investment, the Assessment Review Presentation and how the findings support the Setup Agency Collective relationship.

Next Step

Interested in the Setup Agency Collective?

Start with a conversation about whether a retained relationship could be a fit. If we agree to work together, we will set the Assessment scope in your agreement and begin onboarding after signing.

Talk with Setup about the Collective